Parashat Vayelekh

If Only It Weren't So Violent

The commandments to destroy the seven Canaanite nations are perhaps best understood as a later generation's struggle with idolatry.

Print this page Print this page

Thus the portrait of the conquest of Canaan emerges in Deuteronomy. The military threat of the Canaanite nations as portrayed by the Deuteronomist is insignificant compared to the threat of idolatry. If we had gotten rid of idolatry when we first settled here 600 years ago, the author seems to say, then we wouldn't be struggling with it now.

The Deuteronomist makes a case for the campaign against idolatry in his own time. But that case is projected back to the time of Moses, to a sacred moment in history. Rather than being viewed as a mandate for the annihilation of indigenous peoples, Deuteronomy is best understood as a critique of the idolatrous habits of Jews in a much later age.

Although this explanation doesn't make these passages any more pleasant to read, it does help us to see them in historical context and, perhaps, lead us to ponder whether the task urged upon us by the Deuteronomist has not yet been accomplished.

Did you like this article?  MyJewishLearning is a not-for-profit organization.

Please consider making a donation today.

Rabbi Larry Milder

Larry Milder is one of Jewish musics premier bluegrass guitarists. His most recent CD, American Psalm, features his outstanding flatpicking style, ironic sense of humor, and thoughtful midrash on the Bible and Jewish life. When he is not performing, Larry is the rabbi of Congregation B'nai Shalom in Westborough, Massachusetts.