Barry Shrage argues that Birthright trips to Israel are the ‘miracle’ of our generation because they open the door for thousands of young adults (including the most alienated) to connect to their Jewish identities. More work is needed, however, for Birthright to reach its full potential and combat assimilation. Shrage makes the call for the entire community to engage Birthright returnees through a diversity of follow-up programs in order to secure the future of Jewish life.